Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Capacity; undue influence; fraud; construction; limitation periods

Will Contests & Probate Disputes

What happens if someone contests the will or disputes the distribution of assets?

Quick answer

An interested person may challenge a will based on issues such as lack of testamentary capacity, improper execution, fraud, duress, mistake, or undue influence. Other probate disputes may concern ownership of an asset, the interpretation of a will, a beneficiary’s entitlement, or the personal representative’s conduct. These issues may delay distributions and increase administration expenses while the court resolves the dispute or considers a settlement. Deadlines are strict. A person served with the notice of administration generally must challenge the validity of the will within three months after service, subject to the statute’s limited exception and outer deadline. Prompt review is important because not every objection follows the same procedure or deadline.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

What are common legal grounds for contesting a will?

Quick answer

A will may be challenged if the person lacked the mental ability to make it, it was not properly signed or witnessed, or it resulted from undue influence, fraud, threats, or mistake. Simply believing the will is unfair or disagreeing with how the property was divided is not enough. The person seeking to admit the will must first show that it was properly signed and witnessed. The person challenging the will must then prove the claimed reason.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

How long do I have to contest a Florida will?

Quick answer

A person served with a notice of administration generally must object to the will’s validity, venue, or the court’s jurisdiction within three months after service. The deadline may not be extended except upon the limited statutory showing of fraud, misrepresentation, or misconduct, and even that exception is subject to an outer limit. Other probate disputes can have different deadlines, so the notice, service date, and type of challenge should be reviewed immediately.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Does a no-contest clause prevent someone from challenging a Florida will?

Quick answer

No. Florida law makes a will provision unenforceable if it tries to penalize an interested person for contesting the will or taking another action involving the estate. In other words, the clause does not automatically cause a beneficiary to lose an inheritance merely for filing a challenge. That does not mean every challenge is valid or risk-free. The person still needs standing, a recognized legal basis, and a timely filing, and litigation can increase delay and expense for both the contestant and the estate.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Can a will be challenged because the person had dementia?

Quick answer

A dementia diagnosis alone does not make a will invalid. The question is whether the person had enough mental ability when the will was signed to understand that a will was being made, the general nature of the property, the people who would normally be expected to inherit, and the plan in the will. Medical records and witness testimony may be important, but capacity can change over time. After proper signing is established, the person challenging the will must prove the claimed lack of capacity.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Who pays attorney’s fees in a Florida will contest?

Quick answer

It depends on the work performed and the court’s ruling. Florida law allows a court to award attorney’s fees from the estate in certain probate proceedings, including some services that benefit the estate. The court may direct that fees be paid from the estate as a whole or charged against a particular person’s share. A fee award is not automatic, and the rule that each side always pays its own fees has important probate exceptions.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Can a personal representative be removed during probate litigation?

Quick answer

Yes, but removal requires a legal reason. Florida law lists grounds such as becoming unqualified, failing to follow a court order, failing to account or provide required information, wasting estate assets, or having a conflict that interferes with proper administration. A disagreement with the personal representative, by itself, is not always enough. An interested person may file a petition explaining the grounds, and the personal representative receives notice and an opportunity to respond. The court may also take steps to protect the estate while the removal request is pending.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Can someone file a caveat before a Florida will is admitted to probate?

Quick answer

Yes. A person who may have an interest in the estate may file a caveat asking the clerk not to admit a will or appoint a personal representative without notice to that person. A noncreditor may file a caveat before or after the death; a creditor may file only after the death. A caveat filed before death expires after two years unless renewed. Filing a caveat does not prove that the will is invalid—it preserves notice and an opportunity to object through the probate process.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Can the parties settle a Florida will contest?

Quick answer

Yes. Interested persons may enter a written agreement resolving a dispute about a will, the estate's administration, or how property will be distributed. When the agreement affects people who did not sign, minors, unborn beneficiaries, creditors, or protected homestead, additional procedures or court approval may be required. A settlement should identify the claims being released, the agreed distribution, fees and costs, tax responsibilities, and the steps needed to complete probate. The personal representative must still protect estate obligations and follow any required court order.

Read the full answer
Will Contests & Probate Disputes

Who has the burden of proof in a Florida will contest?

Quick answer

The person asking the court to accept the will must first provide enough evidence that the will was formally signed and witnessed as Florida law requires. A proper self-proving affidavit or witness oath can satisfy that initial step. The person challenging the will then has the burden of proving the claimed reason the will should be rejected, such as lack of capacity, fraud, or undue influence. When Florida's presumption of undue influence applies, the burden shifts as the statute directs.

Read the full answer
Scroll to Top